In 1813, the United States was at war with Britain. Delaware, a Federalist state, opposed the War of 1812 and offered only reluctant support once the country entered the war. After the British Navy bombarded Lewes in April 1813, E. I. and Victor du Pont organized two militia companies at their own expense, called the Brandywine Rangers, made up of men from the powder works and nearby textile mills. Politics were just as tense. On October 5, Delaware voted for governor. Federalist Daniel Rodney won statewide, beating Democratic-Republican James Riddle, but Riddle carried Brandywine Hundred, 234 votes to 210.
When voting began on October 5, Brandywine Hundred voters gathered at George Miller’s tavern for that year’s election. By nightfall, men were bleeding in the road, and both sides spent the following weeks collecting sworn statements to prove the other was at fault. At the center were the mill workers, who walked to the polls together under homemade banners with mottos like “Don’t give up the ship” and “Bees in Peace, Hornets in War” (1111-000-000_07208d). Whether that was a friendly neighborhood stroll or a show of force depended on whom you asked.
Iron manufacturer George Hodgson swore there was “no military array, no call of officers, no mustering of Company” (1111-000-000_07217d). Lieutenant James Phelps of the volunteer company said he got no military order, just a note from E. I. du Pont inviting him, as a manufacturer, to join the walk (1111-000-000_07218d). Victor du Pont, the company’s captain, said the men had “no uniforms, no arms, no drums, no colors” (1111-000-000_07208d).
Others saw a parade. Thomas Beeson swore that more than sixty men marched “in military form with music at their head,” arriving “in rank two deep” (1111-000-000_07209d). John Simmons went further, claiming the men were handed tickets and made to vote under their officers’ watchful eyes (1111-000-000_07178d).
Then came the question of who could vote. Beeson charged that aliens, minors, out-of-towners, and men who hadn’t paid taxes had cast ballots. When he objected, he said the inspector asked only Victor du Pont, who replied, “They are all very good votes. They have paid taxes.” Du Pont says he declined to vouch for ages and asked the inspectors to qualify the voters themselves. He also claims that Beeson called the election fair over dinner that evening. Tavern keeper George Miller heard Beeson and many others say they had never been so far deceived in an election, that they hadn’t thought there were so many votes in the hundred, and that they praised the inspector’s fairness (1111-000-000_07177d).
Several witnesses agree on the first fistfight. Joseph Rigby (1111-000-000_07196d) and Joseph Jackson (1111-000-000_07194d) both heard a man announce he had come to fight and could flog any three Democrats. The man then stripped off his coat and fought with Isaac Dickey, one of William Young’s workers. Miller called for justice and a constable, but none came. The only person he heard call for assistance was Victor du Pont.
The real trouble came later, after dark. In Victor’s telling, an old man warned him that twenty or thirty men on the turnpike were holding big stones. According to du Pont, stones were thrown at his men, striking a dyer named James Brady and cutting his head through his hat. du Pont’s men ran to Miller’s barn, broke up a rack, and charged back armed with the pieces for a ten-minute melee. He insists no one came armed with clubs, only that they grabbed wood once the stones started falling.
Thomas Gray tells it differently. He said he was knocked down and beaten with what he took to be clubs, his hat cut through and his head badly gashed, and he concluded the club-wielders were du Pont’s party (1111-000-000_07182d). Beeson went further and swore his belief that the whole riot was premeditated. By du Pont’s own account, his men did end up with pieces of wood in their hands. The disagreement is over who threw the first stone, and the memorials can’t settle it.
The accounts agree on several important details: a large group of mill workers arrived at the polls carrying banners, questions arose about voter eligibility, and violence broke out during the election. But the memorials offer conflicting explanations of how the confrontation began and who escalated it.
More than two centuries later, these competing accounts illustrate both the value and the challenges of historical research. Even sworn testimony can reflect different perspectives, political loyalties, and incomplete observations. Examining these records together allows us to better understand not only what happened on October 5, 1813, but also how those involved wanted the events to be remembered.
Want to explore the evidence for yourself? Read the original memorials, compare the accounts, and consider what they reveal about election-day tensions in early Delaware.
Browse the 1813 election memorials here.